Car insurance quotes for high risk drivers

Finding the Best Car Insurance Quotes for High-Risk Drivers

In the world of car insurance, high-risk drivers often find themselves facing higher premiums due to a variety of factors that make them statistically more likely to file claims. Factors contributing to high-risk status can range from at-fault accidents, DUIs, and speeding tickets to reckless driving offenses, poor credit, youth or advanced age, and even geographic location.

Understanding the unique challenges faced by high-risk drivers, it’s essential to find the best car insurance quotes that provide suitable coverage without breaking the bank. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore how high-risk drivers can secure the right insurance, the top insurance companies catering to their needs, and the factors that determine their premiums. Let’s dive into the details.

What Defines a High-Risk Driver?

Before we delve into finding car insurance quotes for high-risk drivers, it’s vital to understand what makes a driver high risk in the eyes of insurance companies. High-risk drivers are typically characterized by:

  • At-Fault Accidents: Being involved in accidents where you were deemed at fault can significantly impact your risk profile.
  • DUIs (Driving Under the Influence): A history of DUIs or DWIs (Driving While Intoxicated) is a major red flag for insurers.
  • Speeding Tickets: Frequent speeding tickets can signal a pattern of reckless driving behavior.
  • Reckless Driving Offenses: Acts such as aggressive driving or road rage can label you as high risk.
  • Poor Credit: A low credit score can correlate with a higher likelihood of filing claims.
  • Age: Both very young and elderly drivers may be considered high risk. For example, adding a 16-year-old driver can increase rates by 92%, while rates for seniors can rise from age 70 onwards due to slower reaction times.
  • Geographic Location: Living in areas with a high frequency of claims, congestion, theft, extreme weather events, or high accident rates can impact your risk profile.

Car insurance quotes for high risk drivers

Finding the Best Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers

When you are classified as a high-risk driver, finding affordable insurance can be a challenge. However, shopping around and comparing quotes is a crucial step to secure suitable coverage without draining your finances. Here are some of the best insurance companies for high-risk drivers in different situations:

1. State Farm

State Farm emerges as an excellent choice for high-risk drivers due to its high customer satisfaction rates and affordability. Their comprehensive coverage options can cater to the specific needs of high-risk drivers, offering both security and peace of mind.

2. Erie

Erie Insurance stands out by offering the lowest premiums for drivers with at-fault accidents. If you’ve had a history of accidents, Erie can provide a more budget-friendly solution without compromising on coverage.

3. Geico

For those with a record of speeding tickets, Geico is a top pick. Geico consistently offers the lowest average rates for high-risk drivers who’ve accumulated speeding violations.

4. Progressive

Progressive specializes in providing coverage for drivers with DUIs or DWIs at a reasonable cost. While the premiums may be slightly higher, it’s a reliable choice for those needing coverage after such serious infractions.


USAA is an attractive option for military members and veterans who have had accidents or received tickets. They offer competitive rates and comprehensive coverage options tailored to the unique circumstances of those who have served in the armed forces.

Premium Costs for High-Risk Drivers

To give you a better idea of what to expect, here are the average premium costs for each of these insurers based on different high-risk scenarios:

  • For drivers with an at-fault accident: State Farm, Erie, Geico, Progressive, and USAA offer competitive rates.
  • If you have a history of speeding tickets: Geico consistently provides the lowest average rates.
  • For DUI or DWI situations: Progressive offers coverage at a reasonable cost, given the severity of the offense.

How to Reduce Premium Costs

High-risk drivers can take proactive steps to reduce their premium costs. Here are some tips to consider:

  1. Defensive Driving Courses: Completing defensive driving courses can not only enhance your skills but may also qualify you for discounts with many insurance providers.
  2. Maintain Good Driving Habits: After a certain period of safe driving, some high-risk factors may no longer affect your premiums. Commit to safe and responsible driving to gradually improve your risk profile.
  3. Regularly Compare Quotes: As your risk profile evolves, it’s essential to shop around for quotes regularly. Your current insurer may no longer offer the best rates for your circumstances.
  4. Consider Usage-Based Insurance: Some insurers offer usage-based insurance policies where your premium is determined by your actual driving behavior. This can be a more equitable option for some high-risk drivers.
  5. Improve Your Credit Score: Over time, working on improving your credit score can have a positive impact on your insurance premiums.


In the world of car insurance, high-risk drivers need not be discouraged by the prospect of exorbitant premiums. With the right knowledge and a proactive approach, it’s possible to find affordable and suitable coverage. By comparing quotes from insurers like State Farm, Erie, Geico, Progressive, and USAA, and following the tips mentioned above, high-risk drivers can navigate the insurance landscape with confidence.


Q1: Can a high-risk driver find affordable insurance? A1: Yes, high-risk drivers can find affordable insurance by comparing quotes, completing defensive driving courses, and maintaining good driving habits.

Q2: How long do high-risk factors affect insurance premiums? A2: High-risk factors can affect insurance premiums for varying durations, but some may cease to impact your rates after a period of safe driving.

Q3: What is usage-based insurance, and is it suitable for high-risk drivers? A3: Usage-based insurance determines premiums based on actual driving behavior, making it a potentially fair option for high-risk drivers.


Leave a Comment